Who will carry the defence this season?

Following the 3-0 success over West Bromich Albion in out last fixture, which feels like years ago now, Arsene Wenger attended the customary post-match Press conference and fended off the usual mixture of questions, be they sensible, mischief-making, constructive or inane, he answered with his usual calmness.

One journalistic ‘dipstick’ asked him if Vermaelen & Koscielny were now his 1st choice centre-back pairing, on the face of it a seemingly innocent question, but can you imagine the headlines the following day, if Wenger had actually admitted that that was the case?

The ‘Merde Stirring’ would have gone into overdrive, casting doubts on the future of Mertesaker and trying to create division in the camp. It probably would have rumbled on over the entire international break.

Wenger spotted the trap immediately and danced around the dopey question by stating that Mertesaker and Djourou were all part of his 1st choice centre-backs, although he didn’t include Squillaci, thankfully!

Wenger knows if Arsenal are to continue their present recovery he is going to need all his centre-backs and will need to rotate them to keep them fresh and to avoid fatigue related injury.

Maybe we should add Miquel to the mix as well and wasn’t it good to see Kyle Bartley back in action for Glasgow Rangers? Personally I’d take Miquel and Bartley in front of Squillaci any day of the week.

Thinking of how many centre-backs we have in the squad, and good ones at that, made me cast my mind back to 1992-93, that great ‘Cup Double’ season.

It was a bit of a standing joke about how many centre-backs George Graham had assembled in his squad.

Tony Adams, Steve Bould, Martin Keown, Andy Linighan, David O’Leary, Colin Pates and Steve Morrow were all centre-backs or had been.

Steve Bould spent most of 1992-93 injured and missed all the Wembley games but he starred in the Cup Winners Cup success a year later. Martin Keown was cup-tied but George had been using him as a midfield ‘destroyer’ at the time and unfortunately he missed the Cup Winners Cup Final through injury.

Bouldy was injured, so Andy Linighan had his ‘day in the sun’ culminating with that memorable headed winner in the FA Cup replay, payback to Mark Bright’s snidey elbow. David O’Leary picked up an FA Cup winners medal before retiring in the summer of 1993.

Steve Morrow got the winner in the League Cup after George Graham converted him to a reliable midfielder, before his fall from grace via the shoulder of Tony Adams.

Colin Pates filled-in whenever he was needed and never let us down, the highpoint of his Arsenal career being his European Cup goal against Benfica, he left the club that summer.

Tony Adams carried the back-four on his reliable back that season, no rotation for him and gave me my highpoint of the season.

An FA Cup Semi-Final revenge on the Spuds.

Nice…..

Who will be that man this season or will it be all of them together?

Written by Allezkev

0 0 votes
Article Rating
138 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
TT
TT
14 years ago

Hi all

I hope the Cahill brigade will not go into overdrive in the next few weeks. I have been saying for some time now that we don’t need another CB half as much as we need a new striker and midfielder. our current back 4 are as good as any now and the midfield is tightening up, M’vila and a top striker and we will be well placed.

TT
TT
14 years ago

What for rico? You always play with a settled defense, thats the part of the team that you rotate the least due to the necessity of the players having a very good understanding. Who will you leave out of the team for extended periods? Cahill, Verminator, Merts or Kozzer and do you think that the players left out will want to stick around and warm the bench?

These are all good CB’s and would get a game in almost any other team there is and their omission from the starting 11 would cause problems. The other option would be to play them out of position but that means dropping a midfielder or on of the full backs and ditto we have not only a dis balance but more top players that want out.

3 world class(I consider them to be exactly that) are as much as you can keep happy IMO and adding the forth would not necessarily strengthen us, at least not half as much as a top top striker and midfielder would do.

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

morning all, M’Vila and Poldoski…SIMPLES!!

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

or perhaps verthongen as he can play DM & CB…

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

Morning guys and chicks. Hope you have a good day today.

Good post AK. Keep them memories flooding back in. It sure makes good to remember a bit of history.

But be careful please. Dont you go and say too much about your memories otherwise W.A.T.H. will get to know your age. However can you tell me of your memories way back in the first league championship after the war?? That is if you remember that, ok!!!! 😉

I agree with TT regarding the centrebacks. Too many cooks spoil the broth. Pity AFC did not get Cahill since he is English. But personally I would offer JD and Squilli in return for CAhill. In that way I have 4 centrehalves and play 2 of them in one game and two in another. For example…..Koscielny and Cahill would have the cups, Champions league included while TV05 and Merte would have the league with the CL difficult games included as well.

I would like to have Vertonghen above Cahill for the simple reason that he can play anywhere along the defence plus defensive midfielder.

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

you say “Tomato”…..

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

Morning Rico. The proper use is centreback. Centrehalf came from dropping one of the halfbacks in the 60’s to play two in the middle of the defence and some journos muddled up everything like they usually do. So they coined the phrase centre from centreback and half from half back. However the proper word is centreback although both are used.

itchyballs
itchyballs
14 years ago

“kozzer”is THE MAN!-if we a add vertonghen & a n striker,i’ve a feeling we’ll be laughing!!

Lingberg
Lingberg
14 years ago

Vertonghen and Podolski are on my wish list!

Vertonghen is versatile, can play DM, CB, LB. Very versatile.

Podolski since he is a pure striker. And I think he cab thrive with our system.

TT
TT
14 years ago

If people are worried about Gibbs and Santos then why not buy a LB instead of Cahill which IMHO is not as good as verminator Merts or Kozzer. Cahill is English, so what? The best CB in the prem are foreigners such as Vermalien Kozzer Merts Vidic Kompany etc etc.

Baynes from Everton as LB anyone? I’d have him in a flash over both Santos and Gibbs, at right back Jenkinson is not doing badly and Sagna will be back in January.

Hence I would go for a midfielder and a striker where our need is real instead of going back to the early nineties when we where collecting CB’s like they where going out of fashion.

Adam2
Adam2
14 years ago

So who does Wenger think is best two CB pairings are then ! If all fit and available ? Let’s be realistic here , our defending in away games this season has not been very good – with the CB’s at fault for many of the goals concededed – 8 at United, 4 at Blackburn , 2 at Spuds , 3 at Chelsea, and wins at home over lowly opponents , who are trying to nick a point by defending in depth, doesent prove anything.
I say that we need to see some improvement in our defending in the away fixtures – when Wenger plays with a high line defence that is susceptable to quick counter attacks – and also better defending on set pieces – before smugly deciding that the Centreback issuses have been solved. The Chelsea could have gone either way . Personally I would take Cahill over any of our current CB’s – and Mertesacker was not Wenger’s – first or even second choice was he? . Money got in the way of things again though.
I agree however that another proven goal scoring striker is required to step in and help releave RVP – who according to the Dutch International manager , is running on empty.
And we are only into November!

TT
TT
14 years ago

We want a striker that score goals for fun? Get Remy. With the service he will get at Arsenal he will be in the 20’s goal player.

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Morning all,
rico, were sepp blatter and PHW seperated at birth ?
Word on the street is you got a bit of irish in you kev.
I was there for the fa cup final replay in 93, wrighty was on fire at the time, unstoppable, andy linighan deserved all the plaudits, he wasn’t the most gifted but always gave 110%.
A season to forget for the Wednesday supporters, we were the first team to the the domestic cup double that year.

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Rico, TV5 won’t be playing left back for us, no chance.

Isn’t it possible that wenger could arrange for Santos’s wages to be paid in carrots instead.

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Thats not the Linighan i remember, he was big enough, its just he was surrounded by some great centrebacks at the time and was a bit like the runt in the litter, he did take a bit of stick.

Potter
Potter
14 years ago

Linighan was a good honest player that always gave everything when he played, however he was prone to the odd silly mistake. We used to call it the Andy Linighan moment, as soon as it had gone we knew we were safe for the rest of the match.

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Televisions were much smaller back then.

A few on here are calling for m’villa but midfield is another area where we have plenty of bodies, we’ll probably end up just buying a striker.

TT
TT
14 years ago

Cahill will be going to Chelsea I recon. Either there or Manure. I know lot of fans will be in uproar over it when it happens but I honestly don’t think he will be such a big player to miss as we have those positions covered now. Also I have not by any means given up on JD. He was very good when playing with Kozzer for some time and never really had the benefit of playing with Verminator over a extended period of time which would have helped him a lot.

Give me M’vila, Gotze Remy or Podolsky, any two or three out of that and I would be very excited about our future.

Adam2
Adam2
14 years ago

Hello Rico, this horses for courses use of CB’s all looks good in theory, but what happens when we play sides who are good at attacking on high crosses from set pieces – and also at creating chances from passing moves! This scenario fits all of the top teams who are competing for the European Cup and the Premier League title – top 4 places. So far we have not kept a clean sheet in the league against a top 4 contender – and we have yetstill to play one in Europe.

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

Have a look at this guys and chicks.

Bould said:

“We’ve got some good English kids and I think we’ve always had good English kids and certainly I think there are a lot of good English kids coming through the system. Part of the Premier league program is to get more contact time with the ball we all absolutely agree that this is the way to go.”

“We have Spanish kids, we have Dutch, we have French and Swiss kids. Our top players are every bit as good technically. I guess the problem is that as a country we don’t have enough. So I think that is where everyone is trying to address that problem.”

IMO that is the problem with English players.

It is little wonder that the country is still short in the technique department when people like Tony Pulis, Sam Allardyce and dare I say Harry Redknapp and their ilk are being lauded for their direct style of football.

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Devil, stuart pearce, the england under 21 manager likes to play a bit of long ball as well, says it all really, wilshere would only have ended up with a sore neck playing in that team.

Joaquim Moreira
Joaquim Moreira
14 years ago

Hello!
Always Benfica…
And D. Bent? Isn’t he a good enought for central forward, specially in the League? Isn’t cheaper then the other ones?
Gibs and Santos can play in midfield. But the team will not be balance. yes, we have many Central backs, but didn’t Song play like a central back twice thia season? A player who can play in different positions is always important in a squad. Is the 24th player. How? We must have 2 players for each position and 3 golakeepers. 2×10=20 +3 =23 and more the 24th player. This is the rigth number for a squad. If we are in all the competitions we can have more 1-2 players (normally a midfield and/or back or a forward player). Simples, isn’t it?

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

Morning all, this fixation that people have got about the old back four amazes me, were they better than the back four we have today. was Pele better tham Maradonna questions that can never be answered, Tony and his mates won trophies against teams that were not as fit as we are now, our training and medical treatment is lightyears ahead of how things were then. the speed of Premier football today suprises many new players that join from foreign climbs and a settleing time is needed, i have no doubts that an Arsenal side of today would absolutely kill one of Tonys time, nice to look back at old legends but not to compare, everything is different and you can’t turn back time. All teams have improved since those days and the power of money has changed the top teams our old players would not get a look in nowadays i am pretty sure of that.But great post as normal AK

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

You also have to consider the rules that have changed Offside then was offside and not left to the referee’s discetion the passback rule has been changed probably the goalkeepers steps and holding times have aso been messed about with so many changes makes for diferent results

TT
TT
14 years ago

Rico he will never go to the tiny totts! As for Chelsea they need a quality CB as JT is way past it. Manure has Vidic……………….and IMHO thats it! Rio is long past it and very injury prone and as for Jones and Smalling well they are English and there for world beaters to many. Not to me i have seen nothing from them on a sustained basis that tells me that they are world class. They may well become that but nowhere near that yet. Cahill and Vidic would be ideal to bring those two through and I would not be surprised if old red nose will make a move for him.

And Adam2 I respect everyones opinion and we all have a right to one. but how on earth you can point to Cahill, currently a part of a terrible team defense, as a better defender than Vermailen, Merts (capped 70 times plus for Germany, a far superior footballing nation compered to the English side today) Or for that matter Kozzer is simply beyond me!

We can all point to a terrible start and say our defenders are not good enough but lets analyse that a bit. Who of our current defense was playing at old trafford? Kozzer. All others were out injured so we played with 2 19 year old fullbacks and JD to partner Kozzer. Of these 4 Trarore is gone Jenkinson is coming on in leaps and bounds and JD is a 4th choice. We are steadily improving and a lot of that has to do with midfield and defenders getting to know each other.

As for Merts not being Wengers 1 or second choice go back and read the interview’s with Merts where it comes out clearly that Wenger wanted to buy him LAST year but could not get Bremen to sell. IMO the only reason he also made a bit for Cahill was the doupt over vermalien’s injury.

Lee
Lee
14 years ago
Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Steve, its not a fixation, that defence was a bit special, they hated conceding goals, regarded by some as the best back four in the whole of europe at the time, would have got to show it off a whole lot more if it weren’t for the european ban, the way they went about their business was no mean feat.

TT
TT
14 years ago

Steve very good point on comparing the old defense and the new. The rule change greatly favors the attacker today as IMO it was the other way around in Tony’s day. But hell……they were good though:)

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

Your right Gooners, they were good if not brilliant in their time. Please don’t think i am knocking them.

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Afternoon Gooners.
Afternoon Rico.
Tony Adams resigning?
Wonder if he can do a bit of coaching for us?
Off for a spell to read the comments…

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Rico, looks as if i’ve missed some good chat today.
Lee: 11.00/11.01, agree mate, but M’Vila at £25m could be a bit inflationary for us.
I liked the look of that guy DG was talking about yesterday.
Back to the comments…

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Rico, strange isn’t it, a few months, even weeks ago, a lot of people were coming on here and other blogs complaining about our lack of defenders, particularily central-defenders [DG].
Now we’ve got ppl coming on and saying we’ve got too many.
A couple of injuries in February to our central-defenders [DG] and we’ll get ppl coming on here screaming about why Wenger didn’t buy a defender in January.
A no win situation with football fans… 🙄

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

:'(

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

StevieP, 1.03 & 1.15… Good points mate.
But Keown & Bould, in particular, were intelligent enough and technical enough to have adapted to modern trends, even Adams could have adapted his game.
As far as having too many defenders…
Well, for those that can remember, like Wath, just recall the 1988 League Cup Final that Gus Ceasar handed to Luton Town. When we had only 3 central-defenders [DG] and an injury to O’leary meant Ceasar played. Graham never forgot and made sure he always had plenty of options for central-defence…

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

TT: 11.46, Baines is a good shout and i’d love to see him in an Arsenal shirt.
Being English there would be a premium to pay.
Maybe Wenger has his eye on a left-back equivelent to Jenkinson.
How much more satisfying is it to buy a bargain rather than pay over-the-odds just to garner a few headlines?!

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Mick, my Paternal Grandmother had some Irish in her family.
And i do have green-eyes.
Does that qualify me to join the ‘Green/Gold Army’…? 😉

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

Rico, I think we are up with the chavs!

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Lee, that is great news mate…..
Tomaetoe…

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Rico; 2.39… agree boss.
I am a Cahill fan, the same as you, but Vertonghen could be the answer as he can fill in 3 or 4 positions.
Not sure what his CL situation is..?

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

As far as having too many defenders , i would buy both Cahill and Samba, personally some players play better with different players and in my mind if we could sort out the right pairings everybody could have a break now and again. as AK has said, we are coming to the time when games come thick and fast . I would be inclined to sell who don’t figure or give them away and buy in who do. Same for other positions, if the forwards we have are any good we should be seeing more of them otherwise buy a good un and out the rest, my mind tells me we need a reliable keeper either a top keeper or a very good substitute never stop trying to improve.

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

Besides those four…..PM, LK, TV and if possible Cahill, then there are Bartley and Miguel. That makes it 6. Is that enough??? even a couple of injuries can see us still strong.

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Some say centre-back, some say centre-half, some say central-defender, others like Wath remember when they were called a Third-Back…. 😀
Off to the gym. lata

Adam2
Adam2
14 years ago

TT, my point regarding Cahill is that he is more versatile in regard to defending than our current CB’s are, I think you over rate them somewhat . Mertesacker has always played in German teams and looks to be struggling in our league in away games when Wenger uses his high line attacking tactics .
Your excuses for the hammering at United do not stand up to scrutiny, because anyone elese ,other than Wenger ,on finding themselves in the position regarding player selections that he was in that day ,would have used different tactics to at least keep the score down!
Instead Wenger of this Wenger of course went for goals …

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

Hi Rico, Merts may be ok at the back but as far as positioning goes for corners he lacks that skill i don’t honestly remember him getting on the end of any, and for a guy that big he should stay back.

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

As an old centre forward i used to leave my run in late untill i knew where the ball was going, they tend to stand and wrestle with defenders, and can never get to the ball, wheres the savy in that

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Maybe bergkamp will have a little word in vertonghen’s shell like, get him to see the light.
Diabys winner at old trafford was something else rico.

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

No Rico. I have not given up on Cahill. But I speak as a coach and at the end of the day if my squad can be improved than I am sorry but I have to move a player to make space for someone who is better. It still irks me that we lost Muamba or Diarra when they could have grown with us simply because we had someone else occupying their place and because it suited the slimy toad from spain who wanted his best friend.

All the time I am thinking, in what ways do I improve my team. And I do take decisions even though sometimes they may be difficult.

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Steve, I’d bet you used to put the goalie in the back of the net as well.

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

OOOOpssss. Sorry. I meant JD not Cahill. But you got what I meant didn’t you???

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

Devil, muamba hasn’t been pulling up any tree’s since he left us, diarra on the other hand should never have been allowed to leave, wenger cocked up there, although his attitude did stink, he said we were always going to be a stepping stone in his development, it left us very short in midfield at the time and I think madrid paid 20 million for his services, we let me go to portsmouth for a measly 5 mill.

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

Hi Micko your right there mate, no goalkeeper protection in those days. People went down when they was hurt no diving and no faining injury when a player stayed down for more than five minutes an ambulance was called a proper mans game

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

Micko, you’re worth more than 5 mill imho….

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

I don’t like to brag lee, you know how it is.

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

😆

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

Goonster knee-deep in shims???

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

I reckon we’ll see him on holidays from hell in the next couple of weeks claiming when he went to bed she was definately a woman but when he woke up in the morning she had turned into a man.

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

The Thai floods are getting worse. A Bangkok lady being interviewed on Sky News has just said that the water is now up to her nuts!!

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

Yesterday the comments were passing me and Micko by….

Micko
Micko
14 years ago

I can’t say rico, goonster might do me for slander.

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

If I tell you Rico, I may have to kill you.

mog
mog
14 years ago

it seems that Kieran Gibbs will to undergo a hernia operation.
how many weeks / months will he be missing as someone said earlyer tv could be playing there so perhaps 1 more in the middle in jan.

TT
TT
14 years ago

LOL Adam2 your argument defeats it self! I agree that it was a terrible tactical phuckup that occurred at OT and I can not blame the players for that. Having 20 Cahills will NOT compensate for Wengers tactical nativity any better than the players we already have. As for being versatile let me point to Kozzer and Verm. Both can fill in as fullbacks and both can play in midfield. Verm has played as LB and DM and Kozzer as RB. when we played Barca at the emeraits Kozzer had Messi under tight control and worked like a man marker. I honestly cant see what more we could ask of these two in terms of versatility. And as for Mert he is still new to the team but already brings with him a calming effect that I am sure most of us have noticed. Give him time to adapt better and we have a even better player on our hands.

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Evening Gooners
Where’s Wath?
JM is working no doubt [probably in the pub]…
Mick, £5m, you must Darren Dein as your agent….

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

must ‘have’

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/15772629.stm

Septic Bladder is in the brown stuff again…

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/15779584.stm

Luke Freeman’s gone out on loan.

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

Hiya AK. Pa got everything. So that puts your mind at rest.

AA heading off to Italy for a reported Eur10Mill. Dont know what to make of it. Its in the italian headlines.

Luke Freeman has joined Stevenage for two months. At 18 that can only mean one thing. He will not be making it at the emirates. WSU???

While TH14 is training with AFC. Now do you think that AW should sign him up like Milan did with Beckham?? My heart would like it but my mind says no.

Joaquim Moreira
Joaquim Moreira
14 years ago

Gotenborg-Arsenal – ladies… I think it’s difficult.
Any news for Saturday ?

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

JM, you in the pub…. again… 😉

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Hiya Rico/DG…..
Freeman…. hmm, not sure what to think about that DG.
TH14 around the training ground can only be a good thing.
I think Thierry is thinking more in terms of coaching rather than playing…
Any tips that he can pass can only be a good thing.
Imagine Thierry taking Afobe and Watt for some specialist coaching…

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Chicken curry for me…..
I multi-tasked with the wok… 🙂

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Crap news re: Gibbs.
How did it happen?

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

What happened with Gibbs????

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

Just checked……..Arsenal full back Kieran Gibbs looks to be out until Christmas as a stomach problem has forced him into hernia surgery.

The surgery could keep him out for up to six weeks making it unlikely he will be fit in time for the Christmas programme.

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Gibbs is out until the New Year then?

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Well that’s one defender out!

Rico 😀

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Liandro Damiao, 22, striker.
According to his agent, Arsenal have put in a bid for him.
When the agent starts gobbing off, that usually means no agreement is on the cards.

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

He is just another Adriano……both in skill and in attitude. Better steer clear of him. I wish AW would stop all this malarkey and instead of going towards trouble maker south americans/africans he goes for European quality players like Podolski, Vertonghen, Eriksen.

How many africans do you see at Manure? Or more appropriately at Manure since djemba djemba???

The answer to that is ZILCH

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

gd night Rico. Sleep tight. I wake up at 5.30 everyday.

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Good night Rico…. Soap-time… 😉

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

DG, i’ve got an early start tomorrow,
so i’ll bid you sahha and goodnight.

devilgunner
devilgunner
14 years ago

Sahha to you habib. Righto off to hug the pillow. The prince is already asleep.

Night all

Joaquim Moreira
Joaquim Moreira
14 years ago

Leandro Damiao!!!! In summer I said this name and Gameiro! Nobody listen to me!!!!
I’m quite AW read HH specialy my suggestions 🙂

Lee
Lee
14 years ago

Fucking injuries!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🙁