At least the first week of November is behind us. However, we still have three more weeks remaining in a month that this side has traditionally gone off the rails. Is it a coincidence? I do not think so. We still have too many issues that have not been rectified – issues that are undoing us yet again. Our last game in October (West Ham) was a warning sign; a sign that seems to have gone unheeded. Some of us may have gotten carried away with the wins at Man City and over Shakhtar Donetsk, but many of us are just a little bit jaded by this side – we have seen these flashes before, and know this team is just as capable of the reverse. And so it proved yesterday…

Make no mistake, what started as a bad run of form has become a bad run of results. The October 30 1-0 win over West Ham was a poor performance in which we were able to get three points from. We were not so lucky in Donetsk this past Wednesday, both playing poorly and coming away with nothing. Now this…Last season’s title challenge was built on solid home form, and an ability to beat the sides we were expected to. Early returns suggest we have neither aspect this season. By the second week in November, we have lost three league matches, including two at home to newly-promoted sides. Our other loss, at Chelsea, saw the champions simply allow us to chase our tails and punish the mistakes they knew we eventually would make. Naturally, our loss means we cannot capitalize on Chelsea’s subsequent loss at Liverpool in the late kickoff. I suppose that not falling further behind Chelsea is a blessing in disguise…Or is it??

Not a lot to say about the match itself. We started in the overly casual fashion that many of us have come to know and loathe. Cesc hit the bar with an early free kick, but for all our possession, we did not trouble Newcastle’s second-choice goalkeeper (Tim Krul, deputizing for the injured Steve Harper) until around the 40th minute, when Nasri forced him into a fine save – that may well have been our best opportunity all match. This is the second consecutive game that we conceded immediately before the interval – anyone notice a trend? One related to concentration?

Fabianski is getting killed for allowing Carroll to head unguarded into the net – even Arsene seems to be blaming our keeper on that one. Fair enough, Fabianski could certainly have done better, but his defenders seemed to think that the goalkeeper should have been the one marking the player we knew was going to be Newcastle’s biggest threat on crosses and corners. I see this goal as an entire team mistake. Fittingly enough, not only did it come from Newcastle’s first shot on goal, it came from their first shot, period!

As usual, Arsene changed nothing at halftime – despite the fact that we were playing without a forward, so poor was Chamakh’s performance – it seems apparent that he desperately needs a rest here. A nice Wilshere pass sprung Theo and he hit the underside of the bar with Krul beaten. That was basically as good as it got. Just before the hour mark, Arsene brought Arshavin on for Nasri, and then he later followed with Robin for Chamakh, and finally Bendtner for Wilshere – who was probably our best player on the day. None of the subs had much effect – if anything, they were quickly infected by the malaise engulfing the Arsenal starting eleven. Newcastle did not try for a second goal, but did they really need to? By the end, we were reduced to panic attempts, none of which troubled Krul much. Koscielny was sent off in stoppage time for bringing Ranger down – as the last man, he did what he had to, and the red card was in accordance with the laws of the game.

Now Djorou gets a run of at least three league matches to start alongside Squillaci.

So frustration abounds. Based on our body of work, however, should we really be surprised? We struggle in November, we are not mature enough to immediately bounce back from defeats, and we seemed to show a-not-too-disappointed attitude towards losing in Donetsk in midweek. I think we should have seen this coming…We all thought the players would learn – for once – how coasting through matches and taking specific opponents (i.e. newly promoted ones) for granted can kill momentum and confidence. Both home losses against newly-promoted sides – including one we beat 4-0 in the league cup a couple of weeks ago – indicating the attitude that we can win certain matches just by showing up is, sadly, alive and well. Eradicating this attitude once and for all would be a very good start. I would have thought the players would have learned from the West Brom debacle – yesterday’s performance shows they have learned little, other than perhaps they are not accountable for such β€œefforts” and results.

Now is not necessarily the time for us supporters to demand Arsene’s head, or to β€œblow this up” and start all over. The β€œsack Arsene” brigade is back in full voice – I have never been one of them, and do not intend to join their ranks now. Yet even the most optimistic must concede that things that have undermined us in recent years are doing so again. I speak of a collective sense of β€œcomfort” and complacency amongst the players and a glaring lack of the leadership necessary to turn bad situations into good ones. Simply put, this team has won absolutely nothing as a group, and (I think) shows that they do not yet understand the commitment, application and mature attitudes required to win. Coasting through matches, shrugging off bad results while not applying themselves in the next match, and maintaining the comfortable β€œpass first, pass second, pass third…” philosophy, with seemingly nobody interested in taking responsibility and shooting on goal.

I have long argued that maturity, responsibility, accountability and leadership are sorely lacking within the Arsenal dressing room, and this afternoon’s performance only serves to underline these suspicions. Unfortunately, changes in culture and Arsene’s management style are what I see necessary to fix these things – and I don’t see this happening. Not while Arsene serves as enabler by publicly calling the team β€œunlucky to lose”. Not while his β€œeleven captains” have nobody to grab the players and match by the scruff of the neck and drag them to a win. Not when style takes priority over achievement in everything the club does.

As much as I personally dislike Chelsea and Manchester United, it is no coincidence that those two sides have shared the last seven league titles. Sunday evening, who should top the Premier League table? Yep, those two, just like it has been. Week after week, month after month, year after year. While us Arsenal supporters – and perhaps players – look towards the day when Chelsea’s spine can no longer play at this level, and United’s financial house of cards finally melts down, these sides continue winning. With very few exceptions, they play each competition to win it, and have retained a core of players that have won domestic and European competitions and show their teammates how to win.

We do not have this – like everything else about the current Arsenal model, we have to build it from within. But we have missed a trick by not prioritizing winning the domestic cups as a springboard to success. Other than Arshavin, Campbell, Gallas or Silvestre, I struggle to think of players we brought to the side that have won either European Cups or the Premiership. Without such an infusion of success, the only option is to build winners – but our players cannot yet get over the proverbial hump because they still don’t understand the commitment, attitude and application required. Arsene is now saying the club will make an effort to win all competitions. Perhaps if he had emphasized this a few years prior, we would have won a cup or two by now, and the players would have tangible success to fall back upon when things get tough.

A quick word on two of our players: Marouane Chamakh has had very good start to his Arsenal career. But Arsenal is not Girondins de Bordeaux and this is not Ligue 1. It is evident to me that he badly needs a rest – this was his second consecutive dire staring performance, sandwiched around a similarly ineffective substitute appearance at midweek. He does not look alert, and although he seemed to be trying his best, he could not keep the ball, and was unable to react quickly to the meager service he received. Arsene has overplayed Cesc over the past few seasons, and I would hate to see him do the same with Chamakh. There is no reason to, now that Bendtner is fit and Robin is also back. So give Chamakh a rest, Arsene – he clearly needs it.

I also wish to comment on Lukasz Fabianski: I maintain that he should have done better for the goal, but also had no help from his defenders. Regardless, this was the mistake that we knew would eventually come, and now we will see if he has really turned the proverbial corner. It was impossible to tell in the second half of this match, as Newcastle did not even test him, so we will have to wait for his next start.

Before I address Newcastle and what next, it was not as good to see Robin on the pitch as it should have been. Was he really named to the bench and used as a sub on the basis of a couple of training sessions? Or has he been fit for more than just a day or two? I suspect the latter, and if so, we lose the high ground in Robin’s international selection issue. Now that Robin has appeared here, I do not feel we can justifiably argue that the Netherlands team should not play him – if they are so inclined – for the November 17th friendly versus Turkey (barring another injury, of course). Robin’s selection for the friendly suggests that Van Marwijk knew he was fit – Robin himself probably told him so. If Arsenal were less than forthcoming about his fitness, then all we have accomplished is to pick a fight with the Netherlands FA for no good reason. I would further suggest that his playing in the friendly may help him get match fit quicker. For all our aversion to his playing for his national side, history shows he is more at risk playing for Arsenal, last season’s friendly in Italy notwithstanding. We can use this to our advantage: let Van Marwijk pick him and play him. If Robin comes though unscathed, then he will have another xx minutes of match action under his belt. If he gets hurt again, then he may not have been ready anyways – and then I will assert that Arsene made the first mistake by naming him in the side today. But as long as Robin saw action today, we have completely undermined the argument that the Netherlands should not play him on the 17th.

I would characterize the League Cup win at St. James Park as the most difficult 4-0 Arsenal win I have ever seen. We knew that Newcastle United would bring a stronger side today, and would be even more difficult. What I did not appreciate going in is how effective they are away from home – a win at Everton, and I think more points on the road than at St. James. Yesterday, they did well and deserved the three points in my opinion. Never mind they have only a single chance (two total shots on goal, compared to our three) – they took it and played comfortably in the second half. I thought they counted on our players getting frustrated and petulant and we did not disappoint them. I expect this will not be their last good away win, and if they can sort out their home form, they should do quite well this season. Despite his Spud links, they have the right man in Chris Hughton and I fully expect them to have a very good season.

So, where to from here? We have a midweek league fixture at Molineaux, against a Wolves side that I thought outplayed Man United at Old Trafford on Saturday, and deserved at least a point. Wolves were not easy home or away last season, and I do not expect that they will be again. I am hoping that a quick turnaround and being away from home will help us put in a performance with more intent and effort. Arsene can help the players help themselves by not starting someone (Chamakh) that clearly needs a rest. He can hold players who coast through matches accountable by dropping them. He can be proactive, and change either a player or formation (or both) once we concede a goal, and not wait until the 60th minute. He can stop babying our players (β€œwe didn’t deserve to lose”) – maybe some of them will actually start to grow up. He cannot make the players care enough to do what needs to be done to win, but he can identify the unwilling – and find new clubs for them. He can do a lot of things – much of this starts with him – but not much will change if he does nothing.

Inconsistent? Check. Still immature and collectively mentally weak? Check. Capable of the highest highs and lowest lows, sometimes in the same match? Check. Still incapable of taking that next step from β€œmaybes” to genuine title contenders? Check. Carrying some players that just may not be too bothered about the recent results and efforts? Check.

That is this Arsenal side. That is who we are. We do not have to be this, we should be so much better. But until we first correct the collective team attitude, and then work on the other things, we are who we are.

Written by Oliver