Just two weeks ago, we were on the eve of the League Cup final, looking to use that trophy as a springboard to bigger and better things. As we all know, it went horribly wrong the following afternoon, and I think we clearly have not yet recovered.

We did win our next match, a simple replay drubbing of third-tier opposition, but we have gone from the position of competing for four trophies down to just one remaining, in no time at all. Previous seasons – previous months of March – have seen bad losses have a knock-on effect, with our team unable to recover quickly.At this moment, things seem to be playing out similarly once again. Clearly, this confidence/momentum thing is a hurdle we remain unable to overcome…

Another familiar, depressing scenario is our mounting injury list. We lost our best centre-half in JD on Saturday – I think the Orient replay is the only match in which we have not lost the services of a first team member…Our inability to keep our players fit for the run-in is yet another all-too-familiar hallmark of recent seasons. I think all these factors combine to deplete confidence throughout the team….

Know what? It seems Arsene also feels this way, if his post match comments are anything to go on…He said…verbatim…”You could see something has gone. Not in our effort or attitude but confidence wise.” That is from the manager himself – and probably about as close to an admission that he will give regarding the squad’s fragility…

We are all frustrated and disappointed regarding what happened at Camp Nou earlier this week – but that moment has come and passed, and we needed a strong performance and result today. I think there were certain aspects of our performance which were good, but I don’t think we were mentally strong enough to grab a result…It was there for us, but this inability to bounce back and capitalize has been a continuous problem during the last few years…We simply still cannot seem to overcome our fragile confidence…

To be certain, the opportunity was present today and was an opportunity on at least two levels. For one, a win today would see us in to the FA Cup semi-finals, with a chance to return to Wembley and put the disappointment from thirteen days ago right. For two, it was a chance to win at Old Trafford and show United that we can beat them on their patch, and that we are capable of overtaking them. The former is now irretrievably gone, and the latter will be that much more difficult as United seemed to have added to the psychological edge which (I feel) they already held over us. Namely, the knowledge they can beat us when they need to, and that we have not figured out how to beat them…

United’s team selection provided initial hope, as Fergie named seven defenders in the side. Yet, a closer look showed that with Rooney and Hernandez up front, he probably intended to defend and hit us on the counter. Not for the first time, it worked like a charm.

Arsene named probably as strong a lineup as he could, considering who we have out. The only surprise was Gibbs’ inclusion, so I guess Clichy needed a rest.

Al, Gibbs, Kos, JD, Sagna, Jack, Denilson, Diaby, Arsh, Robin (Captain) and Samir started, with Shea (fourth choice keeper now elevated to deputy), Clichy, Squil, Eboue, Ramsey, Rosicky and Chamakh. No place on the bench for a certain Nik Bendtner, I immediately noticed. I was otherwise occupied on Friday, so if there was news about him being injured, I missed it. On the other hand, if Arsene decided to drop him as a means to get him focused back on what he needs to do for the team, it is most welcome. Either way, Nik’s omission would not make or break us…

Surely we should have been able to overcome the starting eleven United fielded…Shouldn’t we??

The short answer is no, we couldn’t…I shan’t go into a blow-by blow of events as they unfolded; rather I’ll quickly hit the main points. The first thing I noticed was – from the off – how hard United worked. They closed space quickly and Hernandez hassled and harried our defenders. The two things Hernandez did poorly was cross into the box and get easily caught offside. One early instance of the latter ended a promising move for United.

We gradually got our passing game going and started to build some moves. Samir sent a nice cross into the box on one occasion, but nobody was home. This was a problem that hindered us throughout the afternoon – we simply could not (or would not) get players into the box often enough to latch on to crosses or covert rebounds. We controlled possession, but were often sloppy or wasteful with the ball. When United had the opportunity, they broke quickly on the counter – one such early move saw Rafael send a free header over after his brother Fabio got free to cross into the box for him – a warning that United would be dangerous on the counter.

As the half hour mark approached, we had the better of play with no cutting edge. Robin fired one shot straight at Van der Sar from outside the box, but nothing else. Most of our good buildup and approach play had bogged down right around the United box, with players either choosing one pass too many, or (as Diaby often did), holding the ball for too long and ultimately getting dispossessed. United broke on the counter, Rooney had room to feed Hernandez with a cross, and the latter forced Al into a good save.

Unfortunately, our keeper could only push the ball away with his outstretched left hand and Fabio followed up to put the ball into the empty net. Contrast this with several subsequent Arsenal chances, where Van der Sar made initial saves, only to allow juicy rebounds. Unlike Fabio, however, there was no yellow shirt in position to get to any of these rebounds, and there was always a United defender (usually Vidic) on hand to clean up.

The goal stung us into action and we threatened an equalizer, primarily through Robin. First, our captain drilled a low shot in, which Van der Sar tipped around the post. Then Robin got a free header from the subsequent corner, but unfortunately put it wide. Just before the whistle, Samir put a low shot between Evra’s legs, but Van der Sar was able to react and smother it. Despite having the better of the play, we went into the break 1-0 down. As with previous recent meetings, I suspect United were not too bothered, as they were able to pick us off on the counter.

Arsene predictably made no changes at the interval, although I thought both Arshavin and Diaby were good candidates to make way. Our other “lightning rod”, a certain Neves Denilson, played pretty well in the first half, I thought. There were a few instances where he gave the ball away – but the aforementioned pair, as well as Jack and Samir did so too. Denilson’s passing was generally good, he also made a few interceptions – there was one instance where he picked Rooney’s pocket right on the edge of our area – and he played overall well against United’s admittedly weak midfield. However, it was also Denilson who had a big hand in United’s second goal, losing Valencia (who made his return from a broken leg sustained in a Champions League tie versus Rangers) on the counter.

When Arsene made his clockwork on-the-hour substitution, it was Denilson who made way.

About the second goal – it came from a quick break after we had put real pressure on United. Just a couple of minutes into the half, Kos brought the ball out from defence and made a driving run into the United penalty area. His initial shot was blocked, but the ball broke for him, and he forced Van der Sar into a fine save. Quick as a flash, United countered, JD blocked a Hernandez shot, but Rooney was able to collect the ball and head the ball in off the far post from an acute angle. Arsenal heads visibly dropped at this point.

For the next ten or so minutes, we were all over the place as United spurned three good chances to add a third goal. Samir got a sniff of goal, but fired straight at Van der Sar. A minute later, Arsene made the first change, bringing Chamakh on for Denilson. Started to regain control of the ball, maintaining possession moving it to the edge of the box. Much of our joy came through Sagna down the flank – he was often able to get all the way down the field and put several good crosses into the box, but there were rarely yellow shirts in the box. In one instance, he put one right on target to Chamakh, but the latter could only weakly head it directly at the United goalkeeper.

With just under 20 minutes remaining, Arsene made a double change, bringing Rosicky and Ramsey on for Arshavin and Diaby. It was particularly good to see Ramsey finally make his return for us. I would have preferred he started, but it may be that Arsene wanted to ease him back in to the rotation. Regardless, the game became stretched at this point, with both sides getting chances, and both keepers making solid saves.

Rosicky forced Van der Sar into an excellent diving save with a strong shot from (of course) just outside the box. Al made an excellent one –handed stop from Hernandez off another United break. Unfortunately, JD and Sagna collided in a goalmouth melee and the former was down for several minutes before being stretchered off. Post match, Arsene stated JD has a dislocated shoulder and is done for this season.

The immediate effect is that we had to play out the remainder of the match with ten men; the effect on the remainder of our season may be far more costly, considering the latter’s form and importance to our defence. United dominated from here and should have padded their lead, with Rooney and Giggs wasting chances, and Al making more fine saves from Rooney and Hernandez. We have one final sniff deep into injury time, when yet another excellent Sagna cross found Rosicky free in the area. All he needed was to redirect the ball to score, but he missed it completely. We didn’t threaten again and it finished 2-0…

There was late drama when Scholes took out both Chamakh and Jack, but got only a yellow for the first challenge – as if we expected Foy to do anything about it? Nevertheless, the game was long since lost when this happened and we have more important problems than Paul Scholes…

After hearing all week about how we would bounce back, what an opportunity this was, it was discouraging to see a makeshift United side handle us like this. While we made Van der Sar work hard, Al also saved us – United had chances, almost all on the counter, to easily double their tally.

The things most disappointing to me were our pedestrian approach play and our inability to counter at speed. When we dispossessed United, we often broke slowly – there was one instance where a possible break was on, yet Chamakh passed the ball backwards! United ‘s first goal came from a player following up and putting the ball home after a save – we had countless similar chances but never once got a yellow shirt in position to latch on to a rebound.

I also did not particularly like our body language. I could feel the “here we go again” from the players after United got the opening goal. Arsene’s body language was not much better – he shook his head after Arshavin shot nowhere from what looked like a promising move, and looked to me like someone who expected things to develop the way they did. But as Arsene said, we lacked confidence and I think that it clearly showed.

I am not sure how to correct this. One thing I have urged Arsene to do is scale the praise and talk of mental strength back. After the match, he said he thought we could still win the league? How about this time, he does not address that, instead says that we have to work our way out of this and leave it at that? While refraining from publicly criticizing any of the players, his message inside the dressing room can be “Guys, it’s time for you to figure this out yourselves. I cannot play the game for you, you have to stand up and work your way through this.” At this point, could it hurt?

At this point, it is difficult for me to stay positive. Yet I will support as best as I can – at the end of the day, I want our team to win things, be successful and fulfill our potential. I think all of our supporters want that in some way. So it is most disappointing – although not unexpected – to see Arsenal supporters at each other’s throats on the blogs and forums.

Some supporters think things are fine right now and success is inevitable; others think we are headed nowhere and need to blow this up now. Many – if not most – occupy the middle ground and think we are a good side with something still missing. Regardless of what one personally feels about Arsene and the players, we are still Arsenal supporters, and should at least tolerate different opinions, regardless of whether we agree or not.

Some of the stuff I saw this afternoon was absolute poison – how can we give our players the encouragement and boost they need when we slaughter each other like this? I wonder what the players and club staff think when they read these things? As I am sure that many do…

For our players: Guys, just remember who you are and what shirt you wear. Yes, it has been a very difficult two weeks, but now is not the time to sink into self-pity or just give up on everything. We still have a chance to win the league – I will not try and convince you that our chances are as good as they were immediately after the final whistle at Anfield, last Sunday; because clearly they are not…But neither are we out of this – we can still win it, but that will require us to, once and for all, stop feeling sorry about this injury and that bent referee and just focus on the opposition, and getting three points at a time.

The league is still there to be won, if we can rise to the occasion and take it. It starts at the Hawthorns this weekend…

Once again, over to you fellas…

Written by Oliver