Said β€œillusion” being, of course, the possibility that we could still win the league.

Our defeat this afternoon, coupled with Manchester United’s victory of Chelsea a couple of hours later put us 9 points adrift, with only six left to play for – so the best we can now finish is three points off the top.

In truth, such hopes were always an illusion, as we had blown any realistic chances of winning the league with a succession of draws in must-win situations. So we are left with two more games to try and secure third place, and wistfully wonder – not for the first time – what might have been.

We have however, cemented our status as a top four team.

Yesterday’s official arrival of St. Totteringham’s Day meant that we will be playing Champions League football next season. Finishing in the top four season after season is the one area where we have shown the necessary consistency. While I do not want to diminish such an achievement, I do not think it is unreasonable to want more than simply being a top four team every season…

Fresh off the win over Manchester United last Sunday, we headed to the Brittania to face a tough Stoke City side, in yet another must-win situation. The difference in football philosophies and the Shawcross – Ramsey incident from last year’s corresponding fixture added an undercurrent of spite and bitterness. 14 months on, the wounds on both sides have still not healed. We knew what to expect this afternoon…

Arsene named a certain sorely missed but never forgotten Thomas Vermaelen in the squad for the first time since August.

So we lined up Szczesny, Gibbs, Kos, JD, Sagna, Jack, Song, Ramsey, Arsh, Robin, and Theo.

Our bench was Jens, Verm, Squil, Eboue, Rosicky, Chamakh, and Nik.

As usual, we started well, and quickly settled into our passing routine. Stoke, as expected, worked very hard both on and off the ball, closing our players down quickly and trying to deny us time and space. Just five minutes in, Robin had the first real chance of the game after Ramsey played him in; he rushed the shot and sent it high over Begovic’s crossbar.

Just a couple of minutes later, Kos had a chance from the game’s first corner, but he also fired into the crowd. At this point, Stoke had not looked threatening. But, Robin’s chance aside, they had not looked uncomfortable in defence either. Some worrying signs were already emerging for us; the slow buildup, the labored, sideways passing, allowing defenders to get into and hold positions; poor crossing from the flanks, nobody anxious to get into the box.

We have seen these before, and, more often than not, they have portended inauspicious things for our side…

During one of his midweek pressers, Arsene took a couple of minutes to defend our side’s defensive record, reminding those assembled that we have conceded the fewest amount of goals from open play in the Prem this season. Quite correct; however, that is only half of the story.

The other half – which Arsene, quite naturally, did not call attention to – is that we have conceded at/over 50 percent (56, if I recall correctly) of our goals from set pieces. Easter Sunday at the Reebok saw us concede two in losing a game we really should have won.

Exhibit B came just shy of the half hour mark this afternoon. Arsh stupidly fouled Pennant over by the corner flag. The former Arsenal winger delivered the ball into our box, and our defence stood flat-footed, allowing Jones to nip in and actually chest the ball home. JD was badly at fault for Bolton’s winning goal at the Reebok, and he should have picked up Jones on this one. Unfortunately, our young CB was not done with the mistakes this afternoon…

The next ten minutes featured more Arsenal passing for passing’s sake, more indecision, and more reluctance to shoot at goal. We hogged the ball, but Stoke continued to look comfortable in defence.

Stoke then broke out of defence and created a couple of chances, which they couldn’t convert. Unfortunately, they did cash in again five minutes before the break. Jack gave the ball away, and Pennant – who also gave us problems during the February 1-0 win over Stoke at the Ems – was allowed to run in unchallenged on our goal. JD belatedly tried to get across, but his weak blocking effort only succeeded in deflecting Pennant’s shot over Szczesny and into our net. This time, JD was let down by the rest of the side, who stood off and watched Pennant run through…

Stoke should have wrapped things up less than a minute later, Walters slipping past Sagna to crash a shot off the crossbar. We tried to respond and earned a corner in the last minute of stoppage time. Arsh took it, but nobody was home and the whistle went a moment later.

We had lots of possession and little else, other than a 0-2 deficit and a sorry statistic of no shots on goal. Begovic, unfortunately, was not the first goalkeeper to enjoy 45 minutes with nothing to do against us.

Our players’ collective performance suggested a lack of urgency; if this was actually the case, Arsene certainly knew how desperate things were. He took the unprecedented (in recent memory) move of making a non-injury enforced double switch at halftime. Off came Ramsey (who didn’t have a great game returning to a ground with such unpleasant memories for him) and Arsh (who had a poor game), and two forwards – Chamakh and Nik, came on in their places.

This required an adjustment of player roles, so Robin moved from center forward to the hole supporting the forward striker (al la Cesc), Chamakh moved into Robin’s central position, and Nik took Arsh’s wide support position.

No matter, as Stoke was inches from adding a third just a couple of minutes in. They won a corner, Pennant delivered a dangerous ball into the box, and Huth beat everyone to it, heading just over the crossbar. Huth was then involved in handbags with Song, before limping off with a possible knee injury (separate incident) just a couple of minutes later. We seemed to wake up a bit after Faye replaced Huth and Nik shot narrowly wide after good work from Robin.

Chamakh then had a sniff, but screwed his shot badly wide – the guy who wears number 29 for us now looks nothing like the player who scored several vital goals as a lone striker in the first few months of the season. That miss was virtually his only contribution, and he looks a shell of the player, in both form and confidence, who was so important at the start of the season.

Just prior to the hour mark, Robin finally forced Begovic into his first save of the match, with a weak effort. As the minutes went by without a breakthrough looking any closer, a spiteful undercurrent began to show itself in our play.

First Nik earned a yellow for a clumsy and unnecessary challenge on Pennant. Then Jack went in on Pennant studs-up, both players earning cautions for the challenge and aftermath. Pennant and Stoke were perfectly justified – in my opinion – to be angry at Jack’s challenge.

I love that he hates losing and is willing to fight, but this was petulant and borne of frustration; frustration that Stoke were comfortably out playing us and that we couldn’t get anything going. Stoke were not dirty by any stretch of the imagination. They were up for it, played their football and were pretty thoroughly beating us…

While I never want us to meekly lose like we did today, we should still be above this sort of thing…

Pulis withdrew Pennant shortly after, sensibly not want to risk him getting hurt, another yellow or worse, as it had become quite heated out there. With 15 minutes left, we had to go for broke, and Robin had a close range chance, but hesitated and Begovic was able to save at his feet – we really should have pulled one back there.

We forced a series of corners, but were never able to put in a delivery good enough to fashion a chance. Stoke patiently defended and looked for a chance to counter; one such opportunity came when Whelan was put through, but Szczesny tipped the ball around the post.

We were finally showing the necessary urgency and with ten minutes remaining, we wasted an even better chance to pull a goal back. Sagna crossed, Begovic panicked and Robin shot over an empty net from a couple of yards out. Begovic was not the only one who panicked, as our number ten simply rushed his shot when he had time to set and tuck it away.

Arsene made his final substitution, with Rosicky replacing Song. Just a minute later, we finally got on the score sheet, with Robin starting and finishing the move, firing under Begovic to halve the deficit. Ten minutes plus stoppage time – and Huth had required a few minutes treatment – there was still time to get something from this, if not win it and keep our flickering hopes alive.

Sadly, another defensive mistake put paid to any of that, and it was the hapless JD who undid the hope less than a minute after the restart. He rushed a clearance, sending it straight to Walters, who promptly put it into our net.

Game, set, match, season…

The players knew it was done. Heads dropped and Stoke let us have the ball and concentrated on holding their lead. There were four minutes of stoppage time, but the only chance we had was from Nik, who forced Begovic to save deep into the added time. But Stoke saw this out with little difficulty…Halsey’s full-time whistle put us out of our misery.

Before I discuss Arsenal, I wish to give due credit to Stoke City FC and manager Tony Pulis. They were better than us today, better in every area other than time of possession.

We were the side third in the table, still with a glimmer of hope that we could win the title. Stoke came in already booked in next week’s FA Cup final, and comfortable in mid-table (now in eighth place). European football looks likely for them as well, regardless of the result next weekend at Wembley; Man City are on the cusp of qualifying for the Champions League, which would mean an automatic Europa Cup slot for Stoke, win or lose the FA Cup final.

With that final next week, surely it was in Pulis’ interests to take no chances for that match and rest key players in this (relatively) less-important league fixture. With all that considered, why were Stoke the team that showed urgency and clearly wanted this more?

Why indeed? Fine work by Pulis and his team, playing this straight-up and getting a fully deserved win. There is a lesson in this for our players…

So ends a very difficult week for Arsenal Football Club. Seven days ago, we were celebrating a well-deserved win over Manchester United, hoping that perhaps we could still do something this season. Now, amidst the wreckage of another loss, a week of bitterness and frustration over the rise in ticket prices, and more speculation over potential sales of Cesc and Samir, we wonder what next….

We have two games remaining: home against Aston Villa, away against Fulham. We have secured champions league football and a top four finish, so what is left? I still think we should try and finish as high as we can, but will our players? Based on today’s listless, rudderless, insipid performance, I don’t really know…

I am greatly concerned for one Johan Djourou. Through much of the season, he was one of our best players, providing stability and solidity in defence. Two of his last three matches, however, have been frankly atrocious performances. Perhaps it would be in his interests to drop him for these last two games, get him out of the firing line, and let him rest and then get back to work on correcting what has gone so wrong in these past couple of matches.

Then again, it would be completely wrong to single just JD out when so many others underperformed today. I will give Ramsey a pass, as he still looked short of fitness and understandably seems to have some personal demons at this ground. Otherwise, Szczesny, Jack and Robin looked the only players who really tried to turn things around. We had too many others as passengers, and not for the first time. Kinda hard to win matches when three are carrying eight.

Arsene was understandably resigned and deflated afterward. There was nothing about calls going against us, about Stoke kicking us off the pitch, about β€œgiving everything” and β€œlacking sharpness”. No need at all, because none of those things were true. The truth is that the team collectively hid when we needed them to stand up and be counted, as men. You know this, I know this, and Arsene knows this…

Arsene instead conceded β€œsomething has gone” from the team and that we β€œdidn’t compete” today. As always, his words can be interpreted in more than one way, but I think the inference that we lack something is unavoidable. I have no doubt that he knows what are problems are and knows the underlying causes. However you look at it, this is his team, and these are his players. If they have let him down, the proverbial buck still stops with him.

The big question, going forward, will be what he does about it?

I allow myself a wry chuckle as I read the rampant speculation about how selling players x, y, and z while bringing players a, b, and c will cure all our ills. There is something to be said for the argument that our squad may need some freshening up but I also think that the current collection of players we have are good enough to win the league, domestic cups, and possibly more.

One key – again, in my opinion – is devising a way to play that highlights the strengths of as many players as possible, not just Cesc and Robin. That is easier said than done – but I don’t think it is impossible…

That is just one thing I have been pondering – this and the others are for another post on another day. I’ll just say that I don’t think we are far away (from dominating the league and becoming a real force in Europe) at all, and I think we already have much of the squad in place.

I think Arsene can make this happen by compromising on some of his principles, both in man-management, team structure and playing style. Whether he does anything or nothing will dictate much of what happens in next and subsequent seasons.

AstonVilla at home on Sunday, away at Fulham the following Sunday and then into a summer full of questions.

Nothing left to play for other than champions league seeding, so how about we go out and win for winning’s sake?

Written by Oliver