Pereira Linked, Biglia offer and Germans scouted…! Project Youth goes Belly Up!

Well, what else are we doing in Germany??

Our friendly against FC Cologne is long gone and our next fixture is on Saturday in the Emirates Cup against Boca Juniors, so what is the point in staying out of the UK to train? Are we out there to scout players from German sides, or indeed Germans?

Franck Ribery springs to mind doesn’t he and rumours have been rife over the last few weeks about Arsenal being in talks to sign him but we all scoffed at the story because of the £20 Million fee that was suggested. I did wonder if Bendtner could be involved in any deal for Ribery but him being left in England kind of negates that.

Personally speaking, I’m sure there are other players plying their trade in Germany who would be a lot more use to us than him, especially at that price.

Per Mertesacker – Central Defender, Werder Bremen

Marko Marin – Winger, Werder Bremen

Marcel Schmelzer – Left Back,  Borussia Dortmund

Mats Julian Hummels – Central Defender, Borussia Dortmund

That’s just four players in Germany; any one of them would certainly make us a stronger side. Whether or not they are for sale is a different issue but we all know that any player is probably for sale is the right money is offered and that’s where it all falls down for us.

Reports are we’re interested in Alvaro Pereira and it makes sense to link us to every left back on the planet seeing as Clichy is gone but has Wenger not said Gibbs will get his chance?

What about the link to Biglia for £6 Million, this would make sense as we def need a defensive midfielder as we could lose Song and Frimpong to ACON for six weeks in Jan/Feb and then what?

Please no-one mention Diaby…. 😉

Is this Biglia the answer though, yes experienced probably hard as nails but he’s only 5’10”?

Sure Makalele wasn’t tall nor is Mascherano but surely we need at least a 6′ 0″ player in central midfield to protect the already inconsistent back four who are susceptible to an average hoof down the pitch…?

I’d rather spend extra money on Yann M’Vila or Moussa Sissoko who are both taller and younger but both experienced players, is it yet not another case of Wenger looking to buy at Lidl…?

Arsene Wenger won’t play that way, he’d rather got take a risk on a cheaper option. Sometimes it works but all too often recently it doesn’t, especially when it comes to buying defenders.

Thankfully the rumours about Phil Jagielka have cooled; I’m just praying that Wenger has his eye on someone much fitter, much better and much taller.

The departure of JET was confirmed yesterday as he signed for Ipswich, sadly it looks like the next Englishman out the door will be Henri Lansbury. Suggestion is that Henri has posted a comment on Twitter which would suggest his career with us is about to come to an end.

Give him two years and he’ll be banging on the door for England, I truly hope Wenger has a re-think on this one.

Oh, and Middlesbrough look as if they will snap up Rhys Murphy very soon, that will be another one gone then…..

What happened to ‘Project Youth’ Arsene?

Is it time for him to admit is failing, how many of our younger players have been deemed not good enough, the same players he said would be the heart of Arsenal in time. The same players he said would be ‘killed’ if he bought experience, well that old line has worn thin, it’s clearly not working is it?

Another one on the way out seems to be Eboue, reports are that he has now agreed personal terms with Turkish club Galatasaray although afc.com are yet to confirm this rumour but they have confirmed that goal keeper James Shea has joined Dagenham & Redbridge on a season long loan.

Well, Wenger is having a busy summer in the transfer window, shame it’s been all about selling rather than buying though – if the Eboue deal goes through, that’s another £4 Million in the AFC Bank Account….

Great eh!!

Have a good day all, maybe Cahill will sign today? 😉

However, I strongly suspect that neither he nor anyone else will…..

0 0 votes
Article Rating
144 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Will
Will
14 years ago

I am bored with this transfer window.

i am annoyed that the FA, Uefa and Fifa do nothing about the persistant law breakers in the game.

And I am done listening to the Samaritans heading fans who are taking a game way too seriously for their own good.

Dexter
Dexter
14 years ago

Because a few youth team players have been released or sold, you feel it necessary to label it Failed Project Youth?

Give me a break man. You think every fucking kid has to make it?

This blog gets worse, always moaning and bitching, give it a rest

Adam
Adam
14 years ago

Morning Rico. Funny little article in The Mirror on Barca DNA for anyone who hasn’t seen it.

goonerstan
goonerstan
14 years ago

Well at least MARCA thinks we ll be signing MATA pretty soon. That is better than nothing eh Rico…..morning HH

Will
Will
14 years ago

It is a game Rico. Real life is 100 Norwegian kids being slaughted because of a maniacs ideals. Real life is hundreds of thousands of Africans facing deatn because of drought and famine.

Watching 22 over paid tossers chase a ball is entertainment and nothing more.

Wath, he has a right to his opinion and you do and I have to say, this blog has turned a little anti-Wenger in the last month or so.

Steve
Steve
14 years ago

Wenger admitting he got it wrong ? Ha ha. Now that’s what I call fantasy football.

Failure to buy a new left back, failure to buy any central defenders, the arrogant justification for blowing £25m on Nasri for one disinterested season – just another sad predictable Wenger summer.

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Morning Rico. Morning all.
Tried to e-mail you Rico,but there was some connection glich.
Hope your Mum is ok. Pesky carrots eh?
Offski now.

Will
Will
14 years ago

So Wath, you want a dictiatorship on here where everyone has to agree with your opinions or leave?

Nick Escow
Nick Escow
14 years ago

Frimpong has represented England up until now and, given his ability, I would expect him to hold out until he has a better idea of whether he has a chance at an England call-up before he declares for Ghana. Last time I checked the first team squad had Jack Wilshere, Kieron Gibbs and Frimpong seriously considered as starters with Afobe, Bartley and others looking to be named on the bench next season and start to push to be considered “proper” first-teamers. That hardly represents the failure of “Project Youth”. Added to that that we have a number of foreign players who were signed young for tiny fees – Szczesny, Walcott, Ramsey, Song, Djourou, Mannone,Traore, Jenkinson, and Miyaichi. In addition there are a number of strong prospects in the youth system – Aneke, the two new boys from Barcelona, etc. Contrast that with almost any other club in the league and we would appear to have a youth system that is highly reliable and performing well above expectations. You also mention that Lansbury is the sort of player that will be playing for England in a couple of years. Really? He was a sub for the Under 21s. Jack is younger and bossing the England midfield. How many kids have we released who have come back to haunt us? Andy Cole, and that’s about it as far as I can see it. All the others have performed at a lower level than what would be required to make the first team so why hang on to them? Let them go – stick a sell-on clause in the deal and reap the rewards when some market trader turned manager splashes more money than it cost to buy all the rest of the players mentioned above and then loans him out to a club who get relegated but still won’t play him.

Adam
Adam
14 years ago

Arsenal are a broad church but does anyone know if other club’s blogs have quite the diversity of opinion, to put it politely, that Arsenal sites do?

davegooner
davegooner
14 years ago

What is this obsession with tall DMs? Some of the best DMs in the world are less than 6ft. Mascherano, De Jong, Essien, Lass Diarra, Khedira etc. What is important is that they are good tacklers, anticipate danger, powerful and mobile. Everything Alex Song is not!!!

DJ@Dk.com
DJ@Dk.com
14 years ago

Err …

Jack Wilshere.
Gibbs.
Sczesney.
Walcott.

That is a pretty good return for a youth policy if you ask me.

We also have Frimpong coming through who looks good, and the impressive Miyaichi.

Rival teams with young players coming through? I see very, very few.

We can’t compete with Man City and Chelsea because our board don’t want to go down that route. Dein wanted to, he knew that Chelsea and other clubs would take over, and tried to compete with Usmanov. Usmanov now has more cash that Abramovich.

Blame the board, not Wenger.

If you want to buy these big money players, the only option we have is A) Get a sugar daddy with endless cash B) Compete a different way until the bubble for other teams bursts and they have no infrastructure (and may be hurt by FFP rules, but I doubt it — money talks).

It is other teams with so much money they have no need to sell that distort the game at our expense. New threats are Chelsea and City. Why? Because they have endless money.

Wenger is trying to build the equivalent of a Barca academy that makes endless good players.

I like Wenger. I will stick with him.

jim hamilton
jim hamilton
14 years ago

buddy if the current kids are not good enough they should be replaced , surely our beef is that he held on to some for to long . i am pretty sure his youth policy is very much in effect , but we are appearing to be trying to add better quality to the first team and reserves . maybe i have not seen lansbury enough but he does not appear to be a world beater

Will
Will
14 years ago

Wath, he didn’t slag anyone or anything, he passed comment, i am guessing that is still allowed?

Ok guys, those who think Wenger is done. name your new manager, now.

davegooner
davegooner
14 years ago

W.A.T.H., I agree taller players anywhere in the team would be helpful but it is not necessarily a prerequisite for a DM. It is however vital that we sign a tall,commanding, experienced CB that can attack aerial balls and organise the defence. Jagielka is experienced and capable of organising the defence but isn’t tall enough and Cahill isn’t experienced enough to organise the defence. Samba may be your man!!

Adam
Adam
14 years ago

I think the Arsenal blogs this close season have become polarized and quite hilarious. This particular forum is about the most even handed with a range of opinions largely respectfully offered. One site, you know the one, had become positively evil and totally offensive with one truly disturbed cretin leading the charge with many slanderous postings throughout the day. That man needs psychiatric help before he does something bad to someone. Another blog, that majors on all referees being corrupt to explain the team’s failings are at the completely opposite end of the scale. Their close-season postings are slavishly devoted to Arsene but their followers seem based largely overseas and have never watched Arsenal play live. As I said, it’s a broad church. I am just waiting for the shortcomings within the squad to be addressed.

Will
Will
14 years ago

It is his opinion, I think it is getting negative. This used to be a haven of balance but it is now becoming an anti-Wenger, woe is us site and I am trying to bring balance back.

So Wath, who is your new manager?

davegooner
davegooner
14 years ago

W.A.T.H., don’t disagree with much you’ve said. The truth is I would take either of the 3 CBs mentioned and I wouldn’t be disappointed with Biglia or either of the “french fellas”. I just think that there is as much a pressing need for a DM as there is a CB. Alex Song is not good enough and time and time again he exposes our CBs who ultimately get the blame.

Steve
Steve
14 years ago

Surely project youth involved buying dozens of youngsters from all over the world for inflated sign-on fees and salaries. By necessity this meant taking resources from the first team budget.

It has failed because we have produced not even a handfull of players of a required quality. Our return does not even compare with clubs like Aston Villa, Everton or pre-arab Man City.

It has also failed because our starved and depleted first team has not one a trophy for six years.

goonerstan
goonerstan
14 years ago

I know that creep dexter…seen him a couple of times on arsenal blogs….pay him no attention he ll probably go back to sleep. If he thinks HH is anti-wenger wait till he reads today post at LEGROVE…back to arsenal. And I can’t believe am saying this. I might sound like WILL but its most definitely me. Rico u guys should cut wenger some slack. Who have the dirty mancs signed apart from clishit and an unproven CB….they even have crisis of their own…..tevez their captain wants out. The chavs have lost essien for six months and still haven’t replaced him. They have an aging squad and can’t even stomp the cash for fugly faced Modric. Manure have only signed one decent player in ashley young but you all can agree with me that gerv is a better buy. It took barcruptonia all summer to finally bag their “first choice” mid fielder and its taking forever to sign cesc…..so let’s not be hasty people..we have not done badly so far…..and hey am not WILL am stan.

davegooner
davegooner
14 years ago

Lads, Sounds like we’ve cracked it. Now for the small matter of convincing our manager!!

Steve
Steve
14 years ago

If all the Arsenal fansites are getting more and more anti-Wenger posts surely there’s only one conclusion that can be drawn.

This is the internet not the BBC. Here the audience has a voice.

Martin 90
Martin 90
14 years ago

Agree with your article. I wish Wenger would go and take that useless muppet Gladis with him ( they are on total wages of £7 million a year ) but know it will not happen until his contract ends in two years time. Why is it that other teams in the PL can sign up players within a few days and it took us about 3/4 weeks to sign Gervihno (even if a visa was required!). Lots of players from project youth are being shipped out and I am glad that Denilson and hopefullyEboue are leving but still no sighn of any more transfers – just crap PR from the club that they are “working hard” to find new players. No sign of the CB (we really need two!), LB, defensive midfield player and centre forward we desperately need to improve the squad. Next season we will be challenging Liverpool,Spurs and other teams for that 4th spot and our defence at the moment is worse than last year! What are our so-called wonderful scout system doing. The Fabregas/Nasri situation has still not been resolved either.

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

cameroon havent qualified for the african nations cup so song wont be missing in jan wath

afternoon all

cheer up we might be signing mata plus cesc and nasri are staying for another year atleast

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

just eboue and gervinho off init

denilson said cesc is staying so that’s it

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

cameroon are 3rd in their group with 5 points and you need to be top senegal are top with 10

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

yeah frimpong did

Will
Will
14 years ago

Why is it that other teams in the PL can sign up players within a few days and it took us about 3/4 weeks to sign Gervihno

I am guessing you are talking about the two Manchester clubs and Chelsea. I think I will let you work that one out.

goonerstan
goonerstan
14 years ago

Rico I was just humoring u….I really think those two money-bags will move soon….and God help us all when they finally do. Players valuation will go through the roof. Only wish we had done our own bit of business before the impending MAD RUSH

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

oh traore just been called up for senegal

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

2 more

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

of course ghana are through easy they got gyan

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

has frimpong even been called up yet tho

Will
Will
14 years ago

Yes, we have to budget, other teams can waste money and not care.

Mr islington
Mr islington
14 years ago

Wow yesterday was slow and today’s gone nuts.

How did i miss all this 😆

Afternoon everyone!!!

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

coquelin is playing in the u20’s world cup so he’ll miss preseason so another loan in france i think is on the cards last i heard

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

Conor Henderson is expected to be out for a minimum of six months after damaging his cruciate ligaments bit.ly/nnqnUz

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

yo never know he could do an eboue

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

i wait till thats on some thing better than sportsvibe

Mr islington
Mr islington
14 years ago

If we got Mata and a good centre half,i would be very happy!!

Will your starting to sound like the missus and i really dont want to get into the same debate i have about football with her with you.

If you dont understand why people take football to heart,then you will never understand and then theres just no point.

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

RT @Henderson_91: I have damaged my ACL and lateral meniscus and will miss rest of season.I’m absolutely devastated but am determined to come back stronger!

Will
Will
14 years ago

Mr Is. Take it to heart? Yes, life or death? Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

realsocialdad
realsocialdad
14 years ago

wenger said in the latest nike edge vid the lighter you are the better you’ll be

Will
Will
14 years ago

When was the last pre-season or even season we didn’t get a full season injury in?

Will
Will
14 years ago

I can’t remember a season where we haven’t had at least one player out for the most of teh season.

Mr islington
Mr islington
14 years ago

Sorry Will,

Sounded to me like you was starting that football’s just a game lark,I can’t stand that because maybe i’m sad,but i love Arsenal like i love my family!! 🙂

Mr islington
Mr islington
14 years ago

Theo needs to eat more and bulk up…..he’s like a living matchstick.

Mr islington
Mr islington
14 years ago

Na they don’t Rico,when we lose they really put me down in the dumps.

I was born in the whittington hospital at archway and born into a mad gooner family…My dad starting taking me and was hooked straight away.

The stadium,the pitch,the atmosphere everything had me hooked and just couldnt get enough of the Arsenal and they oooze out of every part of me!

Mr islington
Mr islington
14 years ago

I always see him about in the essex road,still lives and breathes Islington…Love good old Charlie.

Adam
Adam
14 years ago

Actually I don’t think we need Mata because, when he recovers from his latest operation, Diaby will be like a new player.

Adam
Adam
14 years ago

You sussed me Rico. I was trying to lighten the mood as I believe we are on the cusp of some major signings. Sorry, I am trying to keep a straight face here.

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

That Diaby.
What a great defensive midfielder…
Wath’s favourite midfield warrior.. 😀

Will
Will
14 years ago

HA ha ha ha ha ha ha. Watching SSN and they are reporting that Agurro (spelling) is looking forward to joining Man City. I wonder why.

arsenal fan
arsenal fan
14 years ago

good post…..
just saw samba play today for blackburn against villa in malaysia…..blacburn lost but he had a great game…..he being in malaysia i hardly think we have made a bid for samba…..

arsenal fan
arsenal fan
14 years ago

start of the transfer window i was quite confident that surely this window he will get atleast one or two top names by now….but im getting really angry….if we have a bad start i really dont care if wenger goes…..

Will
Will
14 years ago

Do you think Wenger will get a CB?

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

Wenger will buy, but not sure who, all i can say is he will be 6’plus and there could be two.

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

Looks like i am on my own again, SteveP what do you think all these so called Gooner fans will say when wenger wins us our first trophy for six years,

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

I think it will go a little like this, ” i knew we were so close and i knew Good old Arsene would come good, and to think fans actually doubted him, but i never did”.

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

Sounds about right SP, Beer

stevepalmer1
stevepalmer1
14 years ago

Meet you there, Nte all.

Joaquim moreira
Joaquim moreira
14 years ago

Hi!
Hello rico! Hope everything is already better!
I’ll be away for two weeks …
I will try to follow Arsenal as I can …
yesterday start the qualifying round of the CL. In Arsenal, players continue to leave.
Right now, we have no team or squad. Without them, you can not do big projects.

Will
Will
14 years ago

Steve, you still around

Joaquim moreira
Joaquim moreira
14 years ago

thank’s rico

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Looks like Wenger has given the green light to the club again attempting to obtain a work permit for Ryo.
Rico, you better keep an eye on SteveP. Next thing he’ll be talking to a giant white invisible rabbit. 😀

oliver
oliver
14 years ago

it seems i missed all the discussion today…shame, this is certainly one where i would be happy to weigh in. unfortunately, i just could not get an opportunity to read the post during the day; by the time i did read it (well into the evening at home, everybody had left for the night…

i see the point you are making rico, but i cannot agree with it. to label it a “failure” on the basis that we are seeing several departures amongst our younger players is to adopt a rather narrow view of the project and how it actually serves our club…

the project is intended to provide an array of talented young players for our first team squad. that, however, is only one purpose. another – perhaps more prominent within today’s model and circumstances – is to provide a series of talented young prospects, all bearing the arsenal brand name, who can be moved on to other clubs at profit to arsenal fc. this, perhaps more than anything, is the heart of the self-sustaining model: the pipeline of talented “diamonds in the rough”, molded and shaped here at arsenal, many with at least limited first team experience by the time they move. almost all sold for profit. transfer fees for our outbound young players may not be eye-popping at first glance – such as the 1.1 mil ispwich town paid for jet. but part of our model is also ensure that sell-on clauses are a part of these transfers – the gift that keeps on giving, if you will. in jet’s case, if the light comes on and he knuckles down and becomes the player we all hoped he would be here at arsenal, it is not inconceivalbe that in a few years time, a bigger, established prem side will buy jet, and we will get a portion of that transfer fee as well. these do add up. these revenues are (in theory at least) reinvested in the squad, either through improved deals for players who arsene feels earned them; or purchases of more youth players to form the bulk of the production line in another few years; or for the purchase of impact players will improve/supplement the first team squad here and now.

the very name “project youth”, implies long-term. deeming such an endeavour a “failure” after a six-year sample size seems very short term indeed. that is not to say i am perfectly happy to have been empty handed these past six years – i most definitely am not. rather, i don’t think it is justified to lay everything at the door of “project youth” there are plenty of issues within the senior squad – not all of whom were a part of “project youth” – that have undermined our title and cup challenges during the last few seasons….

if it were me writing today’s post, i think i would have instead approached it from the viewpoint that our recent acutal (and rumoured) youth player departures, combined with the events of the past few seasons (not all six) lend support to an argument that winning titles with our current model as basis is an uphill struggle. it’s not impossible, of course, but we’ve found the winning silverware a rather difficult nut to crack since leaving highbury…and, as stated earlier, this has been for a variety of different reasons…that is another post, for another day…

i don’t think anybody – not even arsene – reasonably expects all of our youth players to become first-team squad members…that is simply unrealistic, at any level. yet our first team squad has plenty of players that came through our youth system: two goalkeepers, three defenders, six midfielders, and two forwards. a failed system would provide far fewer players to the first team squad. those who are not able to stay in the first squad are subsequently sold off, almost all for a profit. that is the essence of a youth project self-sustainable model: those good enough become part of the first team; those not good enough are moved on for profit, and the next batch of youth players prepares to take the vacated spots.

i cannot call the project a failure, because it is operating exactly as intended: it provides some players for the first team squad, and it sells those not quite good enough for the arsenal first team at a profit. the goal of the club is (should be) to compete for and win trophies at the highest level. whether that actually happens or not, project youth will continue funtioning, and will suport the club in other ways…

nobody should be alarmed at the spate of youth player departures: this is exactly how it should work when there are more players than squad places and some youth players who are simply not the right fit for our first team. this season, we’ll probably see a few of our youth players claim first team squad berths; we’ll see a few of our academy kiddies promoted to the reserve squad; and we’ll see some more youth players moved next summer. and that pattern will most likely continue for the forseeable future…

allezkev
allezkev
14 years ago

Bloody shame about Conor Henderson, out for between 6 & 9 months. Lets hope he’s a quick healer.
Rhys Murphy’s departure will hopefully be only on loan. That kid has had his career crucified by injury. He was a real goal machine before the curse of ‘Diaby’ struck him down. Deserves a huge change in fortune!
Not suprised by JET’s departure, if the ‘whispers’ were anything to go on. Pennant/Bothroyd/Bentley, it’s deja vu.

Will
Will
14 years ago

Where is everyone?