The early season thrashing 8-2 thrashing at Old Trafford seems almost a few seasons ago, as much has changed in the succeeding months. We strengthened the squad right before the end of the summer transfer window and steadily climbed the table, to where we finished calendar year 2011 in fourth place.

Since the beginning of the New Year, however, we have hit a wall, coming from ahead to lose at both Fulham and Swansea, and struggling mightily in an unconvincing FA Cup win over Leeds United. Injuries continue to blight us, as Arteta was ruled out for the second straight match, and none of our first team full-backs are returned…

So we welcomed United yesterday, knowing we owed them something!

Our players may have more or less played down the β€œrevenge” angle during the week but surely some of them had to want to pay United back…

We got a bit of a boost in the morning, with the news TV passed a fitness test and would be available. Unfortunately, Thierry did not, meaning he would not figure today…

We lined up Szczesny, TV, Kos, Mert, JD, Song, Ramsey, Rosicky, OC, Robin, and Theo.

Al, Squil, Yennaris, Miquel, Arsh, Benny and Ju were the bench.

Rosicky’s start in Benny’s place was expected, as the latter did not have a good game in his start at the Liberty Stadium last Sunday. OC’s start ahead of Arsh was a bit more surprising, but welcome, considering how out of form Arsh has been for the past several months.

We started four centre-backs ahead of Szczesny, but the inclusion of three defenders (Squil, Yennaris and Miquel) on the bench meant that Arsene intended to try and keep it a bit tighter.

We started the day in fifth place, and thanks to losses for Newcastle and Liverpool yesterday, we would remain in fifth place (barring another heavy defeat). As Spurs lost at Eastlands in the earlier kickoff and Chelsea dropped two points at Carrow Road on Saturday , this was also an opportunity to make up some ground on the second-fourth placed sides.

Since reaching fourth place on the last day of 2011, we have dropped all six league points we played for and are probably a bit fortunate we have not slid any further than one place.

Yesterday was a golden opportunity to make up some ground on three of the four teams ahead of us in the table and put some distance on the chasers. We don’t get chances like this every week.

United kicked the match off but we started quickly. OC needed only a minute to make his presence known, as he robbed Jones and went on a good run, with Evans having to boot the ball clear in his box. We had the better of the first 15 minutes, as OC and Theo switched flanks effectively and used their pace to good effect. Ramsey and Theo both shot too close to Lindegaard.

There were several previous occasions where we started quickly against United, only to peter out and lose the initiative and that happened in this instance.

On 17 minutes, Jones did his ankle and had to be stretchered off, with Rafael taking his place. While we continue to bemoan our injury situation, it’s worth remembering that we are not the only side short hand. United may not have an entire set of full-backs out, but they came into the match missing both Vidic and Ferdinand, so they don’t exactly have full squad to choose from either…

There was always the concern that our flanks would be a problem, and once United started attacking down the sides, they took control.

Both Nani and Evra gave JD massive problems down the right, and Valencia caused TV problems on the other flank. Szczesny had to save from Giggs at the near post, and ten minutes later, he produced a fine close-range save from Nani, after Evra got away from JD once again.

As the half entered the last few minutes, United were on top…

Two of the worst times to concede goals are right before the break, and immediately after scoring one ourselves. The latter scenario resulted in Swansea’s winner last Sunday, and today we conceded the former. In the first (of three) minutes of stoppage time, Giggs crossed from the left, and TV never picked up Valencia, who ran in to meet the ball at the far post, and head past Szczesny. We were stunned by the goal and had no time to build a response, going into the break at 1-0 down.

Arsene rarely makes non-injury enforced changes earlier than the 60th minute, so it was a bit of surprise to see Yennaris replace JD at the break. A difficult spot for the youngster, to be sure but JD was, frankly, dreadful in the first half, and something needed to be done in that area.

Yennaris then went on to perform well, justifying Arsene’s bold decision. Certainly Evra and Nani got far less joy up that side than in the first half.

We kicked the second half off and got an immediate scare and Robin and Valencia collided. Our captain was down for a few minutes and we feared the worst, even as he got up limping. Fortunately, he was able to carry on and showed no ill effects. We started this half much better and fashioned three good chances in the first 15 minutes, the best coming to Robin, who somehow put Rosicky’s excellent pass wide from point-blank range. A bad and potentially costly miss…

But our heads did not drop and we kept up the pressure. Robin then pumped a cross in the box, but neither Ramsey nor Rosicky could convert. Nani then picked Wellbeck out with a cross into our box, but Mert got across quickly to block on the line. OC then collected Kos’ pass and fired past Lindegaard, but also the post.

We had another scare when Szczesny went down injured – losing him meant Al, who had not played a competitive match for us since his horror show at the Hawthorns late last season. Fortunately, Szczesny was able to continue, and we equalized a few minutes later.

Kos got us going, picking Rafael’s pocket on the edge of our area and finding OC with an excellent pass. OC then found Robin, who calmly finished past Lindegaard to bring us level. With 20-odd minutes remaining, surely we could push on for a winner…

Unfortunately, Arsene contributed to our undoing, substituting OC – clearly our best player on the afternoon and showing no signs of discomfort at this point – for Arsh. The move was greeted with boos and chants of β€œYou don’t know what you’re doing” from the home support.

Our Captain was just as mystified by the substitution, staring at the bench in apparent disbelief. It took only seven minutes for our worst fears to materialize. Just before that, we had another injury delay, as Theo went down hard after clashing heads with Lindegaard when trying to prod the ball home…

Fortunately, he was back on his feet within a few minutes…

Worse followed as Arsh allowed Valencia to blow by him, and the latter found Wellbeck who restored United’s lead with no fuss…

Arsene responded by replacing Ramsey with Ju, but latter, not trusted at any point up to here, made no impact…

Nobody really did…There were six minutes of injury time, but we only really pressed during a small portion – Robin came close to equalizing, and Mert got a shot off. On the other end, Wellbeck went clear and should have made it 3-1, but dithered and we were able to clean it up…

The whistle went shortly after, as we slumped to our third home defeat (in all comps) of this season, and dropped our third consecutive league match…

As stated earlier, we remained in fifth place, but that spot is looking precarious at best. Newcastle are level on points and Liverpool only a single point behind. Even more worrying, Stoke and Norwich are only six and seven points behind, respectively. At the rate we have dropped points this season, we could potentially drop out of the top ten soon, unless we get our act together…

It will be nice to have our injured players return, but how many are really close to returning? And how many will require time and match minutes to get themselves to a level in which they can really contribute?

Unfortunately, our problems run much deeper than injuries…

In November and December, only Robin was scoring – then we were winning. Now it is only him scoring and we are losing…

We have not stopped conceding either. As it is, I think Robin’s fantastic form during calendar year 2011 masked the lack of contribution from other key players. He is still scoring roughly a goal a game, but now it is not enough and there isn’t any sign of anyone else stepping up to fill the void.

Goals from midfield were sparse when we were on our fine run, now they are non-existent. Nobody in defence is scoring, and other than Robin, Theo and Benny have chipped in with the odd goal. Otherwise, nothing…

As they say, β€œIt is what it is…” I didn’t expect any additions during this month, and after this defeat, I still don’t. Arsene used his post-match presser to deliver another sermon on how buying players is so difficult, and how it has to be the β€œright player”, etc…I think most of us reasonable fans get all that.

I would say, however, that our first team squad is loaded with too many of the β€œwrong player”, and that is where our problems are. We have players that cannot stay fit, players that have been out of form for several months now – dating back to the previous season, and players who have shown they are not particularly good.

No different from most squads, really; except that we continue to persist with most of these players and it greatly restricts our squad options.

A couple of days ago, Arsene contradicted our β€œchairman” in saying that missing out on the top four would indeed be a disaster; with less than half the season remaining, that is where we are heading.

If we should ultimately finish fifth or below, having waited forever for certain injury-prone players to return from injury, and persisted with others who have given us next to nothing, will he rue not making the extra effort to bring someone else in during this period, or even purchasing someone in the summer to replace an under-performer or two?

Arsene also used the presser to mount a prickly:’

‘I’ve been inΒ  football 30 years and Idon’t have justify my decisions to you’ defence of the substitution.

We’re well aware of his resume but considering that the player he replaced today’s most effective player with was significantly at fault for United’s winning goal, is it really all that unreasonable to question the substitution? After all, our own captain appeared to question it as well…

Of course it’s reasonable to question.

Not everybody who questions a managerial decision wants the manager out. It’s something that comes with the territory – it’s called accountability. If Arsene does not like that, perhaps it’s time for him to go do something else…

Any way you look at it, this was a bad result. It’s our third league loss in a row, our second home loss of the campaign, and a loss where we basically let five teams surrounding us off the hook.

We have Villa in the FA Cup on Sunday, followed by a trip to the Reebok a few days later. So January 2012 will go down as a month in which we lost all our league fixtures – cannot remember when that last happened.

It’s a worrying sign and with no reinforcements set to arrive, we just have to hope we can get some players back quick, and others will wake up and start producing. If we continue as we are, not only will the top four be a massive, uphill struggle, but any European competition for next season will be a battle as well.

It shouldn’t have come to this…

Written by Oliver